As government debt loads swell to proportions not seen since the Second World War and inflation forces central banks to hike interest rates, investors are having to balance the attractions of some of the highest yields on sovereign debt in more than a decade against the risks of owning those bonds.
And one of the significant risks here is that some countries will face a strike by fixed income investors.
These so-called bond vigilantes have, in the past, forced governments into severe austerity measures by driving up the interest rates at which they were willing to hold freshly issued debt. And now that central banks are no longer able to buy government bonds as freely as they have been for more than a decade, non-state agents once again have the whip-hand in the sovereign debt market.
Which governments’ bonds are most at risk to investor flight is subject to complex factors. Investors need to consider, among other things, volume of debt outstanding, what the outlook for future deficits is, what economic growth is likely to be, what inflationary backdrop central banks face, where future investor demand is likely to come from, how soon existing debt matures and needs to be refinanced.
But one of the most important determinants is who holds the debt.
Such information is crucial because each group of bondholders – domestic central banks, domestic financial institutions, domestic retail investors and foreign investors – will treat the bonds differently, with foreigners much more likely to offload them when times get tough.
Domestic central banks are the most secure holders of their own country’s debt. For much of the past decade, central banks have absorbed significant amounts of sovereign debt onto their balance sheets. That was as part of quantitative easing programmes designed to stave off deflation and bring inflation to statutory target by reducing borrowing costs and stimulating domestic demand, particularly in the wake of the global financial crisis (GFC) – 2 per cent in most cases.
Leading central banks' balance sheets swelled to seven, eight or nine times their pre-GFC norms. But as long as inflation remained low, holding these assets wasn’t especially risky. Real interest rates were negative, and often nominal ones too. There was nothing to stop central bankers from taking a buy-and-hold approach to their bond portfolios; they would draw comfort from the fact that balance sheets would shrink as the bonds matured. They could absorb any market shocks by buying yet more bonds.
Central banks have fewer options now. If recession hits, they could feasibly stop selling the bonds they hold. But it’s unlikely they could begin buying them once more.
Domestic institutions such as banks and pension funds are also often buy-and-hold investors. They are often required to hold safe domestic assets – typically sovereign debt – as regulatory capital. Although here, sudden jumps in bond yields can threaten solvency crises, as occurred in the UK in September last year.
Less reliable are domestic retail investors. Although retail money tends to be sticky, retail investors will abandon an asset if they see running losses, though usually their flight will mark the asset’s capitulation.
Foreign institutional and retail investors are the most flighty. So the bigger proportion of the debt held by them the more sensitive the market is to the risk of sudden investor flight.
Our research shows that the riskiest bond markets are broadly the ones that rely on foreigners. How vulnerable a country’s sovereign bonds are to investor flight is a good proxy for the market’s overall riskiness for investors – as expressed in our sovereign risk model (see Fig. 1).
For instance, Denmark, Switzerland and the Netherlands are the top three ranking countries, ie those with the lowest fiscal vulnerability and are also least at risk of investor flight.
That makes sense. At the end of 2022, Danish financial institutions held the biggest percentage of domestic sovereign debt of any EU country.
On the other end of the scale, substantially bigger proportion of Canadian, Belgian and French public debt is held by foreigners. Factor in the fact that all three have debt loads in excess of 100 per cent of GDP and they all start to look vulnerable to capital flight.
US, French, Austrian and Belgian bonds face the highest level of sovereign debt risk
Of course, being vulnerable to investor flight is only part of the risk equation, if a rather relevant one. The other factors come to play too.
Combining them all leaves investors in US, French, Austrian and Belgian bonds facing the highest level of sovereign debt risk.
The US is in a unique position. Treasury bonds are held globally as a safe asset – investors tend to fly to US sovereign debt during times of crisis. But with such hefty foreign holdings of US debt, an overvalued dollar, high levels of domestic debt and big budget deficits could yet shake confidence in the market. The recent downgrade of US debt by Fitch ratings agency underscores the risks. Fitch cited “erosion of governance”, “expected fiscal deterioration” and “high and growing general government debt burden”.
Solvency concerns for developed country bonds seem far-fetched. After all, central banks have shown themselves to be ready and willing to buy domestic debt in times of market stress, while in most cases the issuance is in the domestic currency – though there are political ramifications in the euro zone. But as the UK showed in the autumn of 2022, market moves can be sudden and dramatic. And a high degree of foreign holding can make them extreme.
Important legal information
This marketing material is issued by Pictet Asset Management (Europe) S.A.. It is neither directed to, nor intended for distribution or use by, any person or entity who is a citizen or resident of, or domiciled or located in, any locality, state, country or jurisdiction where such distribution, publication, availability or use would be contrary to law or regulation. The latest version of the fund‘s prospectus, Pre-Contractual Template (PCT) when applicable, Key Information Document (KID), annual and semi-annual reports must be read before investing. They are available free of charge in English on www.assetmanagement.pictet or in paper copy at Pictet Asset Management (Europe) S.A., 6B, rue du Fort Niedergruenewald, L-2226 Luxembourg, or at the office of the fund local agent, distributor or centralizing agent if any.
The KID is also available in the local language of each country where the compartment is registered. The prospectus, the PCT when applicable, and the annual and semi-annual reports may also be available in other languages, please refer to the website for other available languages. Only the latest version of these documents may be relied upon as the basis for investment decisions.
The summary of investor rights (in English and in the different languages of our website) is available here and at www.assetmanagement.pictet under the heading "Resources", at the bottom of the page.
The list of countries where the fund is registered can be obtained at all times from Pictet Asset Management (Europe) S.A., which may decide to terminate the arrangements made for the marketing of the fund or compartments of the fund in any given country.
The information and data presented in this document are not to be considered as an offer or solicitation to buy, sell or subscribe to any securities or financial instruments or services.
Information, opinions and estimates contained in this document reflect a judgment at the original date of publication and are subject to change without notice. The management company has not taken any steps to ensure that the securities referred to in this document are suitable for any particular investor and this document is not to be relied upon in substitution for the exercise of independent judgment. Tax treatment depends on the individual circumstances of each investor and may be subject to change in the future. Before making any investment decision, investors are recommended to ascertain if this investment is suitable for them in light of their financial knowledge and experience, investment goals and financial situation, or to obtain specific advice from an industry professional.
The value and income of any of the securities or financial instruments mentioned in this document may fall as well as rise and, as a consequence, investors may receive back less than originally invested.
The investment guidelines are internal guidelines which are subject to change at any time and without any notice within the limits of the fund's prospectus. The mentioned financial instruments are provided for illustrative purposes only and shall not be considered as a direct offering, investment recommendation or investment advice. Reference to a specific security is not a recommendation to buy or sell that security. Effective allocations are subject to change and may have changed since the date of the marketing material.
Past performance is not a guarantee or a reliable indicator of future performance. Performance data does not include the commissions and fees charged at the time of subscribing for or redeeming shares.
Any index data referenced herein remains the property of the Data Vendor. Data Vendor Disclaimers are available on assetmanagement.pictet in the “Resources” section of the footer. This document is a marketing communication issued by Pictet Asset Management and is not in scope for any MiFID II/MiFIR requirements specifically related to investment research. This material does not contain sufficient information to support an investment decision and it should not be relied upon by you in evaluating the merits of investing in any products or services offered or distributed by Pictet Asset Management.
Pictet AM has not acquired any rights or license to reproduce the trademarks, logos or images set out in this document except that it holds the rights to use any entity of the Pictet group trademarks. For illustrative purposes only.