Select your investor profile:
This content is only for the selected type of investor.
Individual investor?
The myth of homo economicus
We are pleased to mark Richard Thaler’s Nobel Prize in economics by revisiting his speech at our annual client conference earlier this year.
From the South Sea Bubble in the 18th century to the US subprime mortgage crisis of 2008, the irrationality of human beings has been a persistent feature of investing.
And according to Professor Richard Thaler, a founding father of behavioural economics, irrational forces appear to be gathering strength once again – and in several areas of the financial system.
Take stock markets. Equities have raced to historic highs while their volatility has tumbled to its lowest level in almost 25 years. And all this in a year that has seen shocks like Brexit, Donald Trump entering the White House and the growing threat of a missile attack from a nuclear-armed North Korea.
“So what gives?” Mr Thaler asks. This disconnect, he explained, is yet another example of the flaws of the Efficient Markets Hypothesis (EMH), the idea that the market’s ups and downs follow a logical pattern. Under the theory, popularised by academics in the 1970s and now the intellectual underpinning of passive investing, stock prices instantly reflect all available information. In this framework, humans are rational participants who always make the ‘right’ decisions.
But to Thaler, who has spent the last 30 years dismantling EMH’s various assumptions, people cannot be more different from the utility-optimising ‘econs’ that inhabit the world created by the proponents of market efficiency. Because we are human, we have weaknesses, idiosyncrasies and biases – all of which draw us into making the wrong moves time and time again.
“We behave more like Homer Simpson…Markets have no way of transforming humans into econs,” he said.“Now the market has fallen asleep… yet the world looks really unpredictable
to me. We can make a long list of things that can go wrong.”
Something's gotta give
Investors see stocks rising but also think they're too expensive
Source: Stock market confidence index, Yale SOM International Center for Finance, Institutional investors only.
To demonstrate the market’s possible irrational exuberance, Thaler conducted an experiment with conference attendees. Each member of the audience was asked to predict the performance of the S&P 500 Index over the 12 months to May 2018. The average forecast was for a 10 per cent gain; the lowest forecast was for a return of 7 per cent.
“Investors think the market is overvalued and it’s going up – to me that’s pretty frightening…Looking at any measure, prices are high. I’m not forecasting a crash, but I’m more nervous than usual,” he said.
Valuations are lofty, Thaler reckons, partly because negative interest rates have triggered an unprecedented rush to buy risky assets, regardless of their price.
“People don’t know where to run, so they are staying with what they have on offer,” he said.
The 'hot hand' theory
Another possible behavioural explanation for the market’s steep rally is the ‘hot hand’. This theory describes how people on a winning streak convince themselves – and others considering copying them – that they can sustain this success well into the future. The theory was given the Hollywood treatment in 2015, when Thaler made a cameo appearance in The Big Short, an American film about the global financial crisis of 2008.
It could be that managers they fire may have had a run of bad luck. Investment styles tend to go in and out of fashion. Plan sponsors hire and fire at the wrong time.
![]()
Interestingly, the hot hand doesn’t only apply to picking stocks. It has also been shown to apply to the selection of investment managers. Investors tend to choose asset managers based on their past performance. However, as a growing body of evidence demonstrates, this is no guarantee of future returns. Far from it.
When a pension fund fires a portfolio manager because of bad recent performance, the replacement tends to do worse than the predecessor, Thaler said.
“It could be that the managers they fire may have had a run of bad luck. Investment styles tend to go in and out of fashion. Plan sponsors fire and hire at the wrong time.”
To lessen the effect of the ‘hot hand’ in asset manager selection, investors need to be better at scrutinising returns. This means asking the right questions. “An investor needs to ask ‘what explains your excess returns? Why is it skill not luck and what evidence do you have that it works for the reasons you say it does?'"
Passive irrationality
Another more recent manifestation of irrationality, Thaler explained, is the growing popularity of passive investing.
Active managers have come under scrutiny as investors have grown frustrated by the high fees they have to pay even when the performance is disappointing. In 10 years to 2016, passive funds have attracted nearly USD 1.5 trillion of assets while the share of passive ownership in US stocks has reached 45 per cent.1
But while passive investment might be a rational choice for the individual investor, it makes no sense for the investment community as a whole, Thaler explained.
“If everyone is indexed, the market couldn’t be efficient because there would be nobody setting prices…”
RELATED ARTICLES
Important legal information
This marketing document is issued by Pictet Asset Management. It is neither directed to, nor intended for distribution or use by any person or entity who is a citizen or resident of, or domiciled or located in, any locality, state, country or jurisdiction where such distribution, publication, availability or use would be contrary to law or regulation. Only the latest version of the fund’s prospectus, the KIID (Key Investor Information Document), regulations, annual and semi-annual reports may be relied upon as the basis for investment decisions. These documents are available on assetmanagement.pictet.
This document is used for informational purposes only and does not constitute, on Pictet Asset Management part, an offer to buy or sell solicitation or investment advice. It has been established on the basis of data, projections, forecasts, anticipations and hypothesis which are subjective. Its analysis and conclusions are the expression of an opinion, based on available data at a specific date. The effective evolution of the economic variables and values of the financial markets could be significantly different from the indications communicated in this document.
Information, opinions and estimates contained in this document reflect a judgment at the original date of publication and are subject to change without notice. Pictet Asset Management has not taken any steps to ensure that the securities referred to in this document are suitable for any particular investor and this document is not to be relied upon in substitution for the exercise of independent judgment. Tax treatment depends on the individual circumstances of each investor and may be subject to change in the future. Before making any investment decision, investors are recommended to ascertain if this investment is suitable for them in light of their financial knowledge and experience, investment goals and financial situation, or to obtain specific advice from an industry professional.
The value and income of any of the securities or financial instruments mentioned in this document may fall as well as rise and, as a consequence, investors may receive back less than originally invested. Risk factors are listed in the fund’s prospectus and are not intended to be reproduced in full in this document.
Past performance is not a guarantee or a reliable indicator of future performance. Performance data does not include the commissions and fees charged at the time of subscribing for or redeeming shares. This marketing material is not intended to be a substitute for the fund’s full documentation or for any information which investors should obtain from their financial intermediaries acting in relation to their investment in the fund or funds mentioned in this document.
EU countries: the relevant entity is Pictet Asset Management (Europe) S.A., 15, avenue J. F. Kennedy, L-1855 Luxembourg
Switzerland: the relevant entity is Pictet Asset Management SA , 60 Route des Acacias – 1211 Geneva 73
Hong Kong: this material has not been reviewed by the Securities and Futures Commission or any other regulatory authority. The issuer of this material is Pictet Asset Management (Hong Kong) Limited.
Singapore: this material is issued by Pictet Asset Management (Singapore) Pte Ltd. This material is intended only for institutional and accredited investors and it has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore.
For Australian investors, Pictet Asset Management Limited (ARBN 121 228 957) is exempt from the requirement to hold an Australian financial services license, under the Corporations Act 2001.
For US investors, Shares sold in the United States or to US Persons will only be sold in private placements to accredited investors pursuant to exemptions from SEC registration under the Section 4(2) and Regulation D private placement exemptions under the 1933 Act and qualified clients as defined under the 1940 Act. The Shares of the Pictet funds have not been registered under the 1933 Act and may not, except in transactions which do not violate United States securities laws, be directly or indirectly offered or sold in the United States or to any US Person. The Management Fund Companies of the Pictet Group will not be registered under the 1940 Act.
For US investors, Shares sold in the United States or to US Persons will only be sold in private placements to accredited investors pursuant to exemptions from SEC registration under the Section 4(2) and Regulation D private placement exemptions under the 1933 Act and qualified clients as defined under the 1940 Act. The Shares of the Pictet funds have not been registered under the 1933 Act and may not, except in transactions which do not violate United States securities laws, be directly or indirectly offered or sold in the United States or to any US Person. The Management Fund Companies of the Pictet Group will not be registered under the 1940 Act.
Pictet Asset Management Inc. (Pictet AM Inc) is responsible for effecting solicitation in North America to promote the portfolio management services of Pictet Asset Management Limited (Pictet AM Ltd) and Pictet Asset Management SA (Pictet AM SA).
In Canada Pictet AM Inc. is registered as Portfolio Manager authorised to conduct marketing activities on behalf of Pictet AM Ltd and Pictet AM SA. In the USA, Pictet AM Inc. is registered as an SEC Investment Adviser and its activities are conducted in full compliance with the SEC rules applicable to the marketing of affiliate entities as prescribed in the Adviser Act of 1940 ref. 17CFR275.206(4)-3.